0
Can I play a unit to a battlefield from the trigger of Baited Hook if I sacrificed the only unit at that battlefield?
verifiedAnswer
Ruling: Yes, you can play a unit to that battlefield using Baited Hook even if you sacrificed the only unit there. Because the game is in a Closed State while the ability resolves on the chain, you do not lose control of the battlefield when it becomes temporarily unoccupied.
Sequence:
- You activate Baited Hook by paying its costs and declaring a target friendly unit to kill
- The ability begins to resolve (game enters Closed State with active chain)
- The targeted friendly unit is killed and sent to the trash
- You look at the top 5 cards of your Main Deck
- You choose a unit with appropriate Might (up to 1 more than the killed unit's Might) and play it
- You may place that unit at the now-vacant battlefield or any other battlefield you control
- The chain resolves and the game returns to Open State
Nuances:
- The killing of the unit is not a cost but occurs during resolution of the ability
- Battlefields only become uncontrolled when empty during an Open State, not during a Closed State
- As long as a chain exists (ability or spell resolving), control of battlefields is locked
- This same principle applies to other effects like Arcane Shift that temporarily vacate battlefields during resolution
Comments (0)
No comments yet.
Log in to comment.
Open Proposals (0)
No pending proposals.
Log in to propose edits.